Makemkv - Extract 3DBDISO to MKV - lots of benefits

[mattmarsden]

Ive had a couple of problems with MakeMKV - with Amazing Spiderman it introduces macroblocking on the right eye in the Subway scene and with A Christmas Carol it plays very jerkily. The original ISOs play fine.

[mrnintendo]

Ive had a couple of problems with MakeMKV - with Amazing Spiderman it introduces macroblocking on the right eye in the Subway scene and with A Christmas Carol it plays very jerkily. The original ISOs play fine.

MakeMKV is still beta at the moment.
The macro blocking on the right eye, I also have Transformers in 2 Szenen.Ich suggest Transformers again re-created with MakeMKV and then did not have the macro blocking on the eye.
In I Am Legend, I was ordered to re-create even 3 times because each time in 5 scenes stopped the picture for 1 sec. Otherwise, the program runs but quite well.

[Pash43uk]

Help - tried this on a few 3D iso`s and no matter which video stream i pick i only seem to get a 2D file ?

[jer1956]

Help - tried this on a few 3D iso`s and no matter which video stream i pick i only seem to get a 2D file ?

You have to expand the video stream and chose the MVC stream.

[Pash43uk]

Thanks for the reply , yeh ive done that but still only plays in 2D

[jer1956]

Only ISO will trigger automatic 3d. You have to use name or menu to force 3d with the rest.

[Pash43uk]

Sorted thanks , not sure why but it only seems to work if i mount the image with daemon tools first , then as you say rename to get it to auto select 3D.. Cheers

[Skyliner]

Do you recommend MakeMKV also for 2D BD-Isos?
I have noticted small dropouts only in the Men in Black 3D-Iso so far.
Ok, the size aspect may always be an argument...

[Budge]

I noticed something today.  I just made my first 2 3D BD mkv's yesterday.  The first one, The Lorax, was ripped using AnyDVD-HD and then put through MakeMKV.  The second one, Tangled, I let MakeMKV process the whole thing.  When I went back to play the files today, I noticed that Tangled is showing a split second of "blockiness" in the picture during every scene transition, but The Lorax plays just fine.

I don't know if this means that AnyDVD-HD is doing a better job of ripping 3D-BDs than MakeMKV, or not.  Both films are 24fps, so I don't think this is a frame rate issue.  Has anyone else noticed this?

I'm using firmware version 1.05 on a MED1000X3D.  NSF share with tcp/udp set to Auto and 32k.  1080P 24fps is ON, and Auto Frame Rate is Off.

UPDATE:  This issue is probably not MakeMKV's fault.  I tried playing Tangled 3D as an ISO (without using MakeMKV of course), and the problem was still there.  So it seems the problem must lie with my MED1000X3D or with my network.  Also, it seems the split-second blockiness during scene transitions is only visible in the right eye.  This may be the same was what mattmarsden was reporting earlier in this thread.

[syfer]

Hi their why not take a look at this
http://www.vso-software.fr/products/bluray-converter/bluray-converter.php
and
http://www.xilisoft.com/blu-ray-ripper.html
what do you think?

[Budge]

How do I get Makemkv to burn the forced English subtitles onto the video so I don't have to turn subtitles on every time?

[RobinC]

You can't. That involves re encoding which makemkv doesnt do. If you are set on that route you could use process the mkv using handbrake

[jer1956]

How do I get Makemkv to burn the forced English subtitles onto the video so I don't have to turn subtitles on every time?

You don't have to. The first subtitle will always appear if you have subtitle on in setup.  So  you rip making sure the first subtile is the one you want to see always.

[DarkCinema]

It seems that when playing a MVC MKV3D with original subs embedded  the subs are not shown correctly?
They appear to be in the "middle" instead of in the front. This is not the case when playing the ISO.
This is a pain to watch when  you have to focus your eyes on the subs and back on the movie..

Is there a way to fix this?

[hdmkv]

Re: the filename to trigger MVC MKV 3D, does "3DTAB" need to be at the tail end of the filename? Or can I have something like this?

Avatar.3DTAB (2009).mkv

Also, what about?

Avatar (3DTAB) (2009).mkv