Pages: 1 2 3 [4]   Go Down
Print
Author Topic: Buggy NTFS drivers  (Read 8052 times)
UUBee
Active Member
*
Offline Offline

Posts: 81


Technology is never an excuse for human error.


WWW
« Reply #45 on: November 10, 2010, 02:05:11 am »

I did some investigation and Mede8er seems not the only one with this problem. Its a firmware SDK problem. After looking into the Internet using a simple google I found out that these issues are with the following products:

Mede8er
WD Live
XTreemer
Popcorn
Mac OSX
OpenWRT (firmware for routers)

Actually everyting what is Unix/Linux and uses the Paragon NTFS Driver. So we are stuck with the implementation of NTFS. Maybe there is a possibility to use ext3 out of the box instread of NTFS. Maybe thats why some Mede8er equivalent devices do not support USB Slave Mode so they can use ext3 instead of NTFS.
Logged

2 liters of coca cola, 40 cl of Bacardi....
leuk_he
B8a Tester
Experienced Member
***
Offline Offline

Posts: 139



« Reply #46 on: January 23, 2011, 12:16:44 am »

I got the ntfs-3g driver running on the mede8ter, however i am not really into testing this since i already run the ext3 mod and i am not going to convert

Anybody interested in the files to do some testing with it?  You need te be able to write a basic sh script and to be able to do linux shell script to get this running.


/Edit: i post script and files in the plugondevice topic..
« Last Edit: January 28, 2011, 11:52:59 pm by leuk_he » Logged

===========================
Please fix the Ntfs driver bug, or make ext3 formatting available from gui.
Medi8or
Newbie

Offline Offline

Posts: 38



« Reply #47 on: April 07, 2011, 12:03:24 am »

Dear fellows,

thank you for letting us now about possible NTFS probs.

The key matter is that NTFS is a proprietary file system of Microsoft. Its original design was never revealed (as opposed to free and open software standards). Instead, Paragon & Co. had to re-design their drivers by reverse engineering. So, I'd blame the Redmond monopoly in the first place.

Being aware of this, I stuck to vFAT until recently, when I got my first >4Gig files - and a new built in 4TB HDD...

First, I tried to use ext3 (as I prefer Linux over Windows on my PC as well), but recent fw versions mounted ext3 partitions just read-only.

If there is an increasing number of flaws observed with alternative NTFS drivers, one could ascribe this to
1. increasing size and amount of files combined with increasing sizes of partitions (probably never tested, like y2k bug)
2. statistical reasons (more bytes more bugs)
3. maybe outdated versions of mimicry drivers...

After data loss, it is hard to file bug reports against ntfs-3g or ufsd (which is used in my mede8er), but still your observations should be reported to Paragon and the developers there, I believe.

Now, I regret having chosen ntfs over ext3 and hope being able to switch back some day.

Normally, I copy files using "cp -a" (missing -u and rsync though)...

I will try to understand what your files are meant for - and make the best from them.

Always interested in sh scripts or even extended chroot environments (incl. rsync or even mc?)...

Thank a million - and Mede8er rules!
Regards
M8

I got the ntfs-3g driver running on the mede8ter, however i am not really into testing this since i already run the ext3 mod and i am not going to convert

Anybody interested in the files to do some testing with it?  You need te be able to write a basic sh script and to be able to do linux shell script to get this running.


/Edit: i post script and files in the plugondevice topic..

Yes, interested. Sorry, I posted my reply in the new thread.
Logged
Pages: 1 2 3 [4]   Go Up
Print
Jump to: